Nepal WireChecked. Challenged. Then published.

Economy

Green Onion Price Nearly Quadruples in Kathmandu This Dashain, Data Shows

Cooking oil is up as much as 60 rupees a litre too, and farmers say they still are not paid fairly for what reaches the market.

Street view of Kathmandu's Kalimati fruit and vegetable market, with motorbikes and a car passing under the market's signboard.
File photo: “Kalimati fruit and vegetable market,Kathmandu” by Saddam Hussain Ansari via Wikimedia Commons· CC BY 4.0

Green onion sold for 275 rupees a kilogram on October 12, 26 Asoj, up 266.67 percent from 75 rupees a year earlier, according to Kalimati Fruits and Vegetables Market Development Board data cited by OnlineKhabar. That is about 2 US dollars for one kilogram. Asparagus rose 66.67 percent to 750 rupees a kilogram. Round mushroom climbed 61.04 percent to 525 rupees.

For a family shopping for Dashain, most staples cost more than they did a year ago. Cooking oil, spices, rice, lentils and beaten rice are among them, OnlineKhabar reported, citing the Nepal Retail Trade Association. Sunflower oil is up 60 rupees a litre, to 305 rupees. Coriander powder rose from 300 to 475 rupees a kilogram. The outlet said the rise has weakened the purchasing power of low and middle income households.

The traders' federation chairman blames roads and weather. Kalimati's information officer points to short supply and how traders sell. Bharat Prasad Khatiwada, chairman of the Nepal Fruits and Vegetable Entrepreneurs Federation, told OnlineKhabar that blocked roads after flooding have stopped Indian tomato shipments, driving up prices. A crate of tomatoes sold for 1,000 to 1,200 rupees last week when three to four trucks got through, he said. Bidur Prasad Acharya, information officer at the Kalimati market board, said daily arrivals have risen from about 500 tonnes to 600 tonnes but remain short of demand, partly because traders fear ordering more than they can sell. Acharya also said retail prices stay high because traders sell for a short time in the morning and leave, OnlineKhabar reported. Farmers in Dhading, Nuwakot, Kavre and Chitwan, the main districts that supply Kathmandu Valley's vegetables, told OnlineKhabar that nonstop rain rotted vegetables in their fields. OnlineKhabar reported that the flood on Rasuwa's Bhotekoshi river on 10 Bhadau, in late August, and the rain that followed broke the supply chain, and it has not recovered.

OnlineKhabar's report says middlemen and traders are cartelling and charging what they like, using shortages and transport as the excuse. That is the outlet's own word. No regulator, court filing or named complaint in the report backs it, and neither named source it quotes uses it.

Kalimati's 2018 record

Kalimati has been investigated before. On August 20, 2018, angry traders surrounded a government inspection team at the market, and police detained Khatiwada, then general secretary of the same federation, on a charge of manhandling officials, The Kathmandu Post reported. The Post's report does not say whether he was later charged in court. The investigation that followed found a syndicate of middlemen controlling the supply chain, the Post reported in September 2018. By then the Kalimati board had cancelled permits for 57 of 98 stalls "to end cartel in the vegetable business," Agriculture Minister Chakrapani Khanal said. The Post did not link Khatiwada to any cancelled stall.

What the coverage missed

Traders have blamed the weather before. Ahead of an earlier Dashain, FreshPlaza reported that Khatiwada, then president of the Kalimati Fruits and Vegetables Wholesalers' Association, called talk of price hikes "just rumours" and blamed rain and affected roads. In September 2025, the Post reported consumer rights activists accusing traders of creating artificial shortages during festivals, and said authorities "have failed to regulate prices effectively" despite the same pattern recurring every festive season. Nepal Rastra Bank put vegetable inflation at 10.71 percent in fiscal year 2024/25, against 4.06 percent for prices overall, the Post reported in September 2025.

OnlineKhabar's own reporting also quotes farmers in Dhading, Nuwakot, Kavre and Chitwan saying they still are not getting fair prices even for vegetables that reach the market, raising the question of who along the chain keeps the difference.

What we still do not know

Whether the Department of Commerce, Supplies and Consumer Protection or the Competition Promotion and Market Protection Board, Nepal's anti-cartel regulator, has inspected Kalimati or issued any statement this Dashain.

What farmers in Dhading, Nuwakot, Kavre and Chitwan are actually paid per kilogram for tomato, cauliflower and green onion this year, against Kalimati and retail prices.

Whether the 2018 task force the Ministry of Industry, Commerce and Supplies formed to clean up Kalimati is still active, and whether any stalls flagged then are still operating. The Kalimati board or the ministry could say.

Relief may come slowly. Acharya expects vegetable prices to ease as more people leave Kathmandu for Dashain. Cauliflower and barela, a gourd families favour at festivals, may still climb, he told OnlineKhabar.

Sources

  1. OnlineKhabar · Primary source for this Dashain's Kalimati price data, trade association figures and on record quotes from Khatiwada and Acharya
  2. The Kathmandu Post · Record of Bharat Prasad Khatiwada's 2018 detention during a government cartel inspection at Kalimati
  3. The Kathmandu Post · Record of the 2018 cancellation of 57 Kalimati stall permits to end cartel practices
  4. The Kathmandu Post · Nepal Rastra Bank inflation figures and consumer rights activists' accusation of artificial festival shortages
  5. FreshPlaza · Earlier instance of Khatiwada dismissing price hike reports as rumours and blaming rain
Editorial review record

Why it ran today

  • ranking judge 1: ranked #3 with 60/100. Every household's Dashain budget is at stake, and Kalimati market committee price data is a checkable record the desk can confirm today. The 'cartel' word is OnlineKhabar's own framing. Both named sources blame flood-damaged roads, so the piece leads on attributed price rises and never accuses traders. Weakest dimension: share identity and buried angle, since the cause has been reported for weeks.
  • ranking judge 2: ranked #3 with 60/100. Confirmed. Every household's Dashain budget is at stake, and the Kalimati market committee price list is a primary record the desk can check today, which lifts this single outlet story. 'Cartel' stays OnlineKhabar's framing, and both named sources blame flood damaged roads. Weakest dimension: buried angle, since the supply cause has been reported for weeks.

What the desk dug up

  • The record. The trade-federation chair quoted by OnlineKhabar attributing this year's price rises to flood-damaged roads, Bharat Prasad Khatiwada, was previously detained by police in 2018 during a government crackdown that found Kalimati traders running an organized price-manipulation scheme, after which regulators cancelled dozens of vegetable stall permits specifically to 'end cartel in the vegetable business.' [The Kathmandu Post] [The Kathmandu Post]
  • The pattern. The 'festival demand plus road damage' explanation for Dashain vegetable price spikes has been given by Kalimati officials and traders every year for at least the past eight Dashain seasons, yet the only documented regulatory enforcement against cartel-like behavior at Kalimati dates to 2018, with no evidence any comparable crackdown has followed in subsequent years including this one. [The Kathmandu Post] [FreshPlaza (citing Kalimati board/Khatiwada)]
  • Who benefits. Within OnlineKhabar's own reporting, farmers in Dhading, Nuwakot, Kavre and Chitwan say they are not getting fair prices for the vegetables that do reach market even as retail prices soar - a gap that past reporting attributes to middlemen capturing the markup, not farmers. [OnlineKhabar] [The Record (Nepal)]

Validation

1 red team round, 2 revisions. Decision: approved.

  • accuracy88
  • relevance84
  • defensibility89
  • reach61

Judge 1: The price data is faithfully drawn from OnlineKhabar. But the piece turns a 2018 detention on a manhandling charge into a personal 'cartel record' across the dek, card, hook, take and trigger, which is a defamation risk. It also ignores the ranking order that it never accuse traders. The edits strip that framing and fix the retail label, the misattributed 'headline', the stale NRB label and a flat 'no regulator' claim. The verified price jump is moved onto the card.

Judge 2: All eight edits judge 1 ordered last round are in the text, even though the log lists them as missed. I checked every price, date, name and the 2018 record against the fetched OnlineKhabar, Post and FreshPlaza pages, and they match. The cartel claim stays credited to OnlineKhabar, and Khatiwada's legal status is stated precisely. Some small problems remain, and none justifies rejecting the piece: Acharya's forecast paragraph sits under the 'What we still do not know' heading, the caption's first sentence runs past 20 words, the caption hook reads Kalimati board figures as a shopper's price, and the body runs close to the 700 word ceiling.

The complete record, including the advocate, skeptic, red team and defence arguments, is kept by the newsroom.

#dashain #kalimati #vegetableprices #kathmandu #foodinflation

Readers' comments

Say what you know. A comment shows once the desk has read it, usually within the hour. A question gets its answer from the story's record.